Fanny Mendelssohn - a muted voice
article
D
David Hackett12 min read|12. March 2024
If anyone wanted to make a weighty study of gender inequality in the music of the 1800s - and of its practical and psychological effects on gifted, creative women - Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel would be quite a good starting point.
Living in the shadow of her very famous brother, her own music remained largely hidden during her lifetime. In the 175 years since her death, the neglect that has followed has been almost criminal.
As a young woman Fanny was considered by several respected experts to be just as gifted as her brother Felix. Having shared an impressively varied education, both musical and otherwise, the young Mendelssohn siblings were each other's spiritual and musical soulmates.
And yet when they grew up it was as if an iron curtain had suddenly been drawn between them. Many doors that now opened for Felix were closed just as quickly in Fanny's face. While Felix went out into the world to pursue a highly successful career with his extraordinary talent, his equally gifted sister was left to wither at home. The devoutly Lutheran Mendelssohns believed that the world of professional music was no place for a woman.
Naturally good-natured, Fanny adapted to these restrictions as gracefully as she could. She loved her family and did not want to disappoint it. But the desire to write serious music was nevertheless too strong not to cause a certain inner conflict.
To balance her ambition she constantly assured herself that the family was right, that it did not matter if nobody heard the music she wrote, that she was not ambitious and that she knew her place as an upper-middle-class housewife. But at times a certain frustration boiled over in her letters. Sometimes the frustration even found its way into her music.
According to her mother Lea, Fanny was born with “Bach fugue-playing fingers” - a prescient observation, since at the age of thirteen Fanny was already an expert in the (then still unfashionable) music of JS Bach. When she and Felix later took composition lessons from Carl Friedrich Zelter, the well-connected director of the Berlin Singakademie choir, he remarked at once of Fanny: “this child is truly something special.” Zelter's later praise of Fanny would only too well confirm the misogynistic culture of the time: “she plays [the piano] as well as any man.”
When Zelter began taking Felix with him on tours of Europe to show off his precocious musicality, Fanny was surprised to find herself left behind in Berlin. In her late teens she eventually complained about this to her father Abraham, who explained unflinchingly that it was not a matter of talent but of gender. “Music will perhaps become [Felix's] profession,” he told his daughter,
while for you it can and must be only an ornament, never the root of your being and doing. We may therefore forgive him some ambition and desire to be recognised in a pursuit that seems very important to him, since he feels a calling for it, whereas it does you credit that you have always proved good and sensible in these matters; and it is precisely your pleasure in the praise he deserves that proves you would have earned equal approval in his place. Stay true to these feelings and to this course of action; they are feminine, and only what is truly feminine is the ornament of your sex.
When Abraham noticed about a year later that his daughter was still wavering on the matter, he pressed his position more forcefully: “you must become steadier and more balanced and prepare more seriously and eagerly for your real calling, the only calling of a young woman - I mean the state of a housewife.”
Perhaps such guidance was less shocking coming from a conservative and religious parent, and Fanny might in time still have freed herself from it. But when her beloved brother Felix largely adopted the same line as their father and defended it, especially after Abraham's death in 1835, it left a much deeper mark on her, not least on her creative self-confidence.
Largely thanks to Fanny's good nature, both father and brother believed she was perfectly content with the prevailing situation. Suffering from postnatal depression after the birth of her son a few years later, she complained to Felix that she had not been able to write music for many months. Felix replied that Fanny should instead gladly embrace her maternal duties. He also assumed that Fanny would now give up composing: “you must often have other things to think about now than composing beautiful songs, and that is a great blessing.”
Felix did not seem to consider that behind Fanny's fundamentally easy-going nature there was a restless young artist who simply wanted the chance to do what every restless young artist wants to do - to prove herself, to be performed, to measure herself against the highest standards and even to receive proper recognition for her efforts. And from this creative restlessness Fanny never quite managed to free herself, as she admitted herself: “That I keep at it [composing] despite a complete lack of outside encouragement I again interpret to myself as a sign of talent.”
She really did keep at it, arranging time for composing almost every day. Since she could not expect her works to be performed publicly (“the home is stage enough for a woman,” her father declared), a large part of her output consisted of songs (lieder) and piano music. Even in these, the originality of her ideas and the level of craftsmanship were striking. She created a new kind of piano miniature known as Lieder ohne Worte (Songs without Words). Although this was a musical genre that her brother developed later and which became famous, the evidence now strongly suggests that it was Fanny who invented the form.
Felix particularly admired Fanny's song compositions and occasionally had them printed in his own collections, though exclusively under his own name. This led many years later to an embarrassing situation when Felix met the young Queen Victoria, who expressed an interest in singing one of Felix's songs that she especially liked: Italien. Slightly flushed, Felix had to admit that the song in question had been composed by his sister.
But Fanny could also help herself in other ways. Above all she could find herself a husband who would support her in a way neither her father nor her brother was capable of. When at around 18 she met Wilhelm Hensel, a handsome former soldier who had become a court painter, she fell for him at once. Despite initial family opposition they married five years later, and for Fanny it was one of the best life decisions she ever made.
Rather than expecting her to devote all her time to the duties of a wife, Wilhelm had already made it a condition of the union that Fanny should have unrestricted access to her music. Before leaving for his painting studio every morning, Wilhelm would lay out music paper and writing materials on his wife's desk and encourage her to compose something before dinner time. Unlike Abraham and Felix, Wilhelm always urged his wife to publish her music. Unfortunately Fanny's strong loyalty to both her brother and her father had muddled her head on the whole matter, and many years passed before she followed her husband's advice.
Felix's own attitude to Fanny's professional aspirations only hardened over the years. When even his own mother reproached him for his inflexible way of thinking, Felix told her: “from what I know of Fanny, I would say she has neither inclination nor calling for authorship. She is too much of everything a woman should be, for that. She looks after her home and thinks neither of the public nor of the musical world, not even of music at all, until her first duties are fulfilled. Publishing would only disturb her in those, and I cannot say that I approve of it.”
But there were still options open to Fanny, not least because she realised she could still achieve something as a musician on a more domestic level. In 1831 she revived an old family tradition of private concerts with a series she called Sonntagsmusiken (Sunday music), held in the Mendelssohns' spacious Berlin home near the Tiergarten. She drew up the programmes herself, played the piano, organised her own choir and conducted. Most importantly, the concerts gave her the opportunity to perform her own music.
Private these occasions may have been, but they were far from narrow-minded. Her guest list was full of distinguished names, such as Franz Liszt, Niccolò Paganini, Clara and Robert Schumann, the young French composer Charles Gounod and the German poet Heinrich Heine. While the guests listened in rapt silence, Wilhelm would often make quick sketches of them or invite them to sit for a portrait afterwards.
Encouraged by the success of the Sonntagsmusiken series, Fanny also tried for the first time writing larger-scale works, which she could then programme in concerts.
Her Oratorium nach Bildern der Bibel (Oratorio on Images from the Bible) is the third and greatest of the three cantatas she wrote in 1831. The music takes as its starting point models from before Classicism - JS Bach and Handel - but then transforms them into an expressive, early Romantic context (roughly in the same way as her brother did in his later oratorios, Paulus and Elias). For an eight-part choir accompanied by a full orchestra (reinforced with extra trombones), the music positively bubbles over with inventiveness as it rushes from one section to the next, and its rapidly changing moods are handled with a skilful and supple touch. All in all, great things would be expected from any other 26-year-old composer showing the same assurance of technique and music.
But when Fanny showed her cantatas to Felix, he was unusually critical and nitpicked over details of the orchestration. Might he possibly have felt that Fanny was straying too far into his territory? Be that as it may, his sharp reaction had a damaging consequence: Fanny wrote no more cantatas - in fact she wrote hardly any other orchestral works either, even though she had shown a clear aptitude for such music.
Something similar happened when in 1835 she wrote a string quartet in E-flat major - possibly the first string quartet ever written by a woman, and one that ranked highly alongside any other work of the genre at the time. But again Felix's reaction was surprisingly negative. And in defending the work in a somewhat pleading letter to her brother, Fanny managed to convince herself that she could not write in longer forms. “I lack the ability to sustain things properly and to give them the necessary coherence,” she wrote, quite wrongly, as it turns out.
In a more desperate moment Fanny asked herself: “what does it matter, my compositions? Nobody cares about them, and nobody dances to my tune.” She once complained that her music went unnoticed, even in her home town. “Once a year someone perhaps copies a piece from me or asks me to play something special - certainly no more often ... If no one ever voices an opinion or shows the slightest interest in one's output, one loses in time not only all pleasure in it but also all ability to judge its worth.”
But if the 1830s had been a long period of frustration and self-doubt for the composer Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel, the 1840s would bring long-awaited redress. A significant turning point in her life was the nine-month journey that she and Wilhelm made to Italy in 1839 and 1840 - also the first time Fanny spent a significant period away from her family. Better still was the genuine admiration and respect Fanny felt from many of the musicians she met along the way.
In Rome they met the young French composer Charles Gounod, a recent winner of France's prestigious Prix de Rome, and quickly became warm friends with him. Gounod was in fact genuinely dazzled by Fanny (evidence suggests he may even have been in love with her): “Madame Hensel was a very learned musician and played the piano well. Despite her small, frail figure she was an exceptionally intelligent woman, full of energy, which could be read in her deep, fiery eyes. On top of all this she was a very gifted pianist. She had rare gifts for composition, and many of the ‘Songs without Words’ that were published among her brother's works and under his name were hers.”
Gounod was able to give the older woman, to a certain extent, a self-confidence that she had not known before, and he was not the only one who admired her. Looking back on her time in Italy, Fanny remarked that “in my early youth I was never courted as I am now, and who can deny that it is very pleasant and flattering.”
One of the first fruits of this creative renewal was a set of piano pieces that she wrote in 1841 to depict all 12 months of the year, Das Jahr. The score was written on specially tinted paper alongside fragments of poetry, and her husband added to it a series of delightful illustrations. It became one of Fanny and Wilhelm's most beautiful collaborations.
Word of Felix Mendelssohn's gifted but largely unknown sister began gradually to spread. Further encouragement came in the form of Robert von Keudell, a young amateur musician and future diplomat, who became a trusted adviser and confidant. Then in the mid-1840s Fanny met the virtuoso pianist and composer Clara Schumann (Robert's wife) for the first time, and the two women took to each other almost immediately. Clara described Fanny as a “kindred spirit” and “the most significant female musician of her time.”
They probably had much to talk about, not least because both were working on piano trios at the time. But while Clara's own G minor trio is carefully polished and full of classical balance, Fanny's D minor trio takes more harmonic risks and adopts an almost wild and fervent energy. All in all, this is music that shows us quite another side of a woman who could be so insecure about her creative gifts; it demands our attention, and its emotional arc is touched by something close to full-blown anger.
As a major chamber work of the 1840s, the piano trio seemed to foreshadow a new phase in Fanny's creative development, and it remains one of her greatest achievements.
Her reputation continued to rise. And rather than going after publishers, they eventually came to her, when two Berlin publishing houses approached her in 1846 and invited her to put together a package of her works. At last Fanny decided to defy Felix and accept the offer, writing to her brother soon afterwards:
Laugh at me or not, as you like: I fear my brother at 40 as I feared my father at 14 - or, more aptly put, I want to please you and everyone I have loved all my life. And now that I know in advance it will not turn out that way, I feel QUITE uncomfortable. In a word, I am about to publish ...
Having given her brother a moment to take a deep breath, she went on:
I hope this does not disturb you in any way, for as you see, in order to spare you any possible unpleasantness I have proceeded entirely on my own, and I hope you will not think ill of me. If it succeeds, that is, if people like the pieces and I receive more offers, I know it will be a great stimulus for me, which I have always needed in order to create. If not, I am at the point where I have always been, and I am not sorry; and if I were then to work less or stop working altogether, that too would lose nothing.
Although it took Felix a whole month to reply, as if he had needed time to absorb the news, his better side eventually won out: “only today, hard-hearted brother, do I set about answering your kind letter,” he wrote. “I send you my professional blessing on joining the profession - may you have much good fortune in delighting others; may you taste only the sweetness of authorship and none of its bitterness; may the public throw roses at you, never sand.”
Such words meant the world to Fanny. “Felix has written,” she noted in her diary, “and given me his professional blessing in the kindest way. I know he is not quite content in the depths of his heart, but I am glad he has said a kind word to me about it.”
Three sets of Lieder and a further three sets of Songs without Words (for solo piano) were duly published as Opp. 1-7 under the name Fanny Hensel. All received unanimously positive reviews.
It seemed that Fanny was at last emerging from her brother's shadow. She began preparing more manuscripts for publishers. The following spring Felix noted that he had never seen his sister “looking so well and healthy”.
Unfortunately, time was also quickly running out for her, in a way nobody could have foreseen.
On the morning of 14 May 1847 she read a very flattering review of her song set Gartenlieder (Op. 3) in a respected German music journal. Later the same day she was holding a new rehearsal at home for the Sonntagsmusiken series when she suddenly lost feeling in her hands. This had happened before, and Fanny did not panic unduly but left the room to rub them with vinegar and told the choir to carry on singing. “How beautiful that sounds,” they heard her call from the next room. These proved to be her last words - a moment later she had collapsed from a ruptured blood vessel in the brain, and within a few hours she was dead.
When the news reached Felix (who was in London at the time), it practically crushed him. He did not get back in time for the funeral and, after visiting Fanny's grave, wept almost without pause for several weeks. As if now fully realising the madness of having helped suppress her music for so long, he immediately set about arranging further publications of her compositions and managed to get two more sets of Lieder, some piano pieces and a piano trio into circulation (all eventually published in 1850). He also took the time to write his own musical memorial to his sister, his touching and elegiac String Quartet in F minor, Op. 80.
But Felix was not a well man himself by this point, and years of chronic overwork together with his own inconsolable grief hastened his own tragically early death six months later, also following a catastrophic stroke. Before that he had expressed the wish that death is a place where there is “still music but no more sorrow or partings.”
Had the two siblings lived another thirty or forty years, as better health really would have allowed, it is quite likely that Felix would have overcome his prejudices and fully accepted his sister as a fellow composer, while Fanny might have flourished as never before and written many more significant works.
Above all she could have served as a role model and standard-bearer for other female composers trying to clear a path for themselves in the late 1800s - a time when the world was gradually changing its attitude to women composers, though very slowly.
But it was not to be - and sadly most of Fanny Mendelssohn's music remains unpublished, unperformed and entirely unknown today.
More of David Hackett's writing at www.musicbytheyear.com
The article was first published on Live Klassisk in March 2024.
