Kolme suurta pianistia, osa 2 - Radu Lupu

Three great pianists, part 2 - Radu Lupu

article
D
David Hackett7 min read|14. June 2024
Radu Lupu often gave the impression of having wandered onto the concert platform by mistake. Stocky, unsmiling and modestly dressed, with long, straggly hair and a slightly wild beard, he barely acknowledged the audience as he shuffled to the piano. Many music critics compared him to a disappointed bear. Others said he resembled a shaman, a wizard, a Jeremiah-like prophet or even an anarchist of the early 1900s. Very few thought he looked like a pianist.
He did not sit on a stylish, padded piano stool whose height can be adjusted with side levers, but on an ordinary, high-backed chair. And instead of hunching close over the keyboard (à la Glenn Gould), Lupu leaned back in his seat and adopted the posture of a painter about to start work at a fresh canvas. Which, to some extent, he perhaps believed he was.
But then a miracle happened - he began to play. For Alex Ross of The New York Times it was “hard to describe exactly what happens when Radu Lupu's fingers touch the piano. There are no showy gestures, no dazzling triumphs of technique and no surprising interpretive insights. No great personality hurls the music at the listener. First what happens is that the piano gives an intoxicatingly beautiful tone; individual lines or open intervals take on a luminous glow. Subtle dynamic shadings, clear inner voices, well-shaped rhythms and singing phrasing follow - after that nothing, or something eerily like the music itself.” For many it was an almost otherworldly process. In Fiona Maddocks's words, Lupu seemed to be “taking dictation by ear from the ether.”
His playing had to be heard to be believed, and preferably live, although he rarely allowed his public recitals to be recorded. Every performance was a unique event for him, every piece a musical story to be told. He could be passionate and stormy, but more often the audience was moved by his astonishing subtlety. He made every piece sound completely lucid through a combination of flawless articulation and a deeply felt understanding of the music.
Above all his playing was organic. It was as if the piano had merged with his soul and was his primary means of communication. “Music could never have come closer to speech,” wrote one critic after hearing him play. For another, Lupu had “that mysterious something that goes beyond technique, learning and general musicianship and reaches into the sensibilities of the listeners.”
Outside the concert hall he was a man of few words, even with colleagues he got on well with. He almost never gave interviews (“for fear of being misunderstood or misquoted,” as he put it), hated all publicity and self-promotion, and much of his private life remained a mystery to the outside world. But whenever he touched the piano keys, this same deeply private man seemed to open up his innermost self to the strictest public scrutiny.
So who was this superb but enigmatic pianist? Radu Lupu was born into a Jewish family in the Romanian city of Galați in 1945. His musicality was evident from the start, and according to his parents Radu expressed himself by singing before he could talk. He was also creative. Although he began studying the piano at the age of six and showed real talent for it, his life's goal was not the concert platform: “I considered myself a composer,” he said in 1970. “I was sure, and everyone else was sure, that one day I would become a famous composer.”
And although it is hard to believe now, much of this was connected with Lupu's early technical difficulties at the piano: “I found even the basics of piano technique very difficult,” he once admitted, “because it demanded great self-discipline, and because I had imagined for years that I would one day become a composer, I had always felt that such perfection would not be needed.”
Lupu eventually changed his mind about this in the middle of his teens, around the time he was accepted at the Bucharest Conservatoire. Two years later he won a place at the Moscow Conservatoire, a rigorous school that probably helped him shape his dazzling technique.
Progress was so rapid that the former bungler soon won three major piano competitions in the late 1960s - the Van Cliburn International Piano Competition (Texas, 1966), the George Enescu International Competition (Bucharest, 1967) and finally the Leeds International Piano Competition (1969). “I really do not like competitions at all,” Lupu confessed afterwards: nobody was more surprised at his success than he was himself.
It also sent his life in an entirely new direction: “I became a celebrity overnight,” he said, “and I simply had to face it. Before that I had probably felt subconsciously that I needed time to develop. I was very principled, and all I felt was that I had to cancel those concerts that did not seem to fit my studies. I did not want to be put under pressure to learn something specific for this or that concert. But after Leeds my life changed completely. It is uncharted territory, there is a lot of pressure, and one does not know whether one will cope.”
But his growing reputation also gave Lupu the opportunity gradually to set his own terms for orchestras and concert promoters and to decide which piano music he now wanted to focus on. That is why his 1800s repertoire was mostly Austro-German, especially Beethoven, Schubert, Brahms, Schumann and Mozart. From the 1900s he was more likely to play Eastern European colleagues such as Bartók, Enescu and Janáček. Unlike Maurizio Pollini, he rarely played contemporary music, although a piano concerto written in 1971 by the Polish composer André Tchaikowsky was dedicated to him.
Andrew Patner, a Chicago writer and journalist, was once bold enough to tease Lupu about this, telling him: “Maestro, sometimes I think that as you play fewer and fewer pieces and play each one better and better, there will come a time when you play only one piece, but your performance of it will be incredible.”
Lupu replied deadpan: “how did you know?”
At times Lupu seemed to do only the minimum to get by. His demeanour often suggested lethargy and a mildly depressive nature, and he did not always look after his health. He could also be painfully modest. The only pianist he was ever heard to criticise harshly was himself. But those who got to know him always found him good company, and a dry humour glinted from beneath the shy exterior. The cellist Stephen Isserlis would recall with warmth Lupu's “deep laugh[,] which was a constant in every conversation.”
According to Lupu there was only one supreme rule in his playing - that “everything in music starts in the head ... If you have any idea of the sound, you hear it in your inner ear. All you have to aim for is to get that sound to correspond on the instrument. The whole balance, line and tone is conceived and controlled in the head.” Largely for this reason he found he could at first read a new piece “more easily further away from the instrument.”
Related to this, Lupu was always obsessively interested in the balance of tones. “Do not underestimate the incredible control of his playing,” fellow pianist Mitsuko Uchida once said of him. For Lupu himself, physically touching the keyboard was “a very individual matter, determined by the colour or sonority that one hears and tries to achieve, the piece being played, the phrase.”
At other times Lupu could be disarmingly honest about his own shortcomings, not least because his profession did not always suit his temperament. “There are times when I am not in the mood to play, and yet my schedule says I have to play,” he admitted. “That means I should have great discipline, but that is a quality I never, never will have. I am a great romantic. I have to feel everything I do; it has to be spontaneous.” The problem was reconciling creativity with creative obligations: “There are days when I would love to make a record but I have no sessions planned, and others when I am due to make a record and would like to get out of it - mike fright, you could call it,” he said in 1976.
Although much of Lupu's playing was based on musical instinct rather than technical theory, he was famously exacting when it came to making recorded music. Although he made over twenty recordings for Decca Studios in London between 1970 and 1993, the collaboration was not always a happy one. One novice recording engineer recalled that “unknown to me, nobody else at Decca wanted to work with [Lupu]. He was famously difficult, neurotic, insecure and in a constant state of frustration. In my ignorance I believed my job was just to spot wrong notes, mark them in the score and do a retake. Wrong notes were Lupu's smallest concern. They usually began with the piano and the Steinway technician, who would file or brush a special fluid onto the hammers to even out the tone, brightness and dullness of every key. Lupu would play something and then ask: ‘Is the F# too bright? I will play it again!’ The technician went back into the studio and spent the next 30 minutes with the innards of the piano in his lap.”
Even in his best years Lupu was not the most prolific performer. But when poor health began to trouble him in his sixties, his appearances became rarer still. Lupu often cancelled several concerts at short notice, but then suddenly turned up at some unexpected venue to offer his services. Desperate not to miss him, people hurried there from far away.
After collapsing and spending several months in hospital in 2018, he knew his time was running out. He gave his last performance in Lucerne in June 2019, playing Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 23 in A major. “Radu played like an angel,” says Stephen Isserlis, who also took part in the concert, “a soft angel, perhaps saying goodbye; but all so natural, so simple - Mozart as he should be played (but so rarely is).” Equally memorable was the encore with which he finished - the heartfelt first intermezzo of Brahms's Op. 117 set.
And that was it from Lupu, for three years later, in April 2022, came the sad news of his passing. We can only be grateful that he left behind as much of himself as he did. So many of his recordings are revelatory. He could make even a familiar piece sound like something you were hearing for the first time.
And what about Lupu's own ideal pianist? “I would look for someone who would tell me a story I could believe, someone who would combine manner of performance, technique, knowledge, culture, sincerity, projection and personality - genuine playing.” He could just as well have been describing himself.
You can read more by David Hackett at www.musicbytheyear.com
The article was first published on Live Klassisk in June 2024.