Three Great Pianists, Part 3 - Alfred Brendel
article
D
David Hackett7 min read|12. July 2024
Alfred Brendel has always maintained that as a child he had only two piano teachers, neither of them particularly distinguished. “The first spent a lot of energy strengthening my small fingers,” he recalls, “for which I am grateful. The second said that I was tense and that I should relax. He didn’t tell me how, but it was interesting to work it out for myself!”
Working things out for himself would be a recurring theme of Brendel’s early career. Afterwards he was grateful that he had not been a child prodigy from “a musical family, an artistic family or an intellectual family.” From his teens onwards he was given a certain freedom to train at his own pace and in his own way.
The result has been one of the most original and profoundly thoughtful pianists of the last sixty years. There are no frills and no empty virtuosity in Brendel’s playing. His interpretations have instead been marked by complete clarity, sharp insight and deep emotional power. He is the ultimate “substance before style” artist.
Doing things his own way has been one of his trademarks. “I value my independence greatly,” he once said. “I am not a member of any club, party or creed [and] I have no nationalistic feelings of any kind.” The view was shaped in part by a childhood divided between Czechoslovakia (where he was born in 1931), Croatia and Austria, at a time when all three were overshadowed by far-right political movements.
Brendel never forgot the experience of living in countries ruled by either the Ustaše (the Croatian fascist movement) or Nazi Germany. As he puts it himself, “the experience of war, of bombs, of proud political ‘believers’, of the insane voices of Hitler and Goebbels on the radio, of seeing Jews wearing yellow stars and of the approaching war with my mother at my place of residence left in my memory a store of knowledge, knowledge that told me in retrospect what the world should avoid being. It… inoculated me against all fanaticism and nationalism.”
Although during the war he partly had no access to a piano, Brendel had still progressed enough on the instrument to give his debut solo recital in Graz at the age of 17 - “a strange and very complicated programme,” as he remembers it. The concert was titled “The Fugue in Piano Literature”, and he played music by Bach, Brahms and Liszt as well as a double fugue he had composed himself. Brendel always regarded composition as an essential part of understanding how music works. “I urge every young pianist to take composition lessons and try composing,” he once said. “When you learn how a piece holds together, you gain a different perspective.”
He was now shaping a more general approach to becoming a concert performer. Although technical skill was of course an essential part of it, Brendel believed that it could develop fully only together with a close understanding of the score. “I am not talking about dry analysis,” Brendel explains, “which is relatively easy if you know how. I do the opposite. I get to know the piece and wait for it to tell me what it is about and what makes it a masterpiece.”
Through long hours of practice Brendel carefully shaped his performance, not only by reading the score precisely but also by ceaselessly recording his practice sessions. He played back every recording and listened for anything that sounded even slightly wrong. “What did I do?” he would ask himself whenever he heard something suspect. “Did I emphasise something too much? Did I emphasise too little? Did I do the right thing, but not to the right degree?... There are many possibilities. Sometimes there are small corrections that make an enormous difference.”
Although he placed third in the first Ferruccio Busoni Competition in Bolzano in 1949 (Brendel’s only notable competition success in his entire career), he was never tempted to pursue fame for the sake of fame alone. “Impatience was not among my vices,” he says. “I didn’t feel the need to reach the top within a few years.” His talent was rather a “long-term project. When I was 20, I wanted to achieve certain things by the age of 50, not by 25. I was not without ambition, but it was not a burning, self-destructive ambition. I was thinking of works that deserved to be done justice.”
The whole process would be gradual, its upward steps almost imperceptible. “Perhaps no other pianist of our time has so determinedly avoided the usual routes to success and the formulas of stardom and yet ended up at the top of his profession,” wrote the New York Times some years later.
With the Busoni prize safely in his pocket, Brendel settled in Vienna for the next two decades. Besides giving concerts, he benefited from the flood of small and medium-sized American record labels arriving in the city. “There were fine halls to record in,” Brendel recalled, “and young talents queuing up. In those post-war years the premises in a city divided into British, American, French and Russian zones were relatively cheap and the wording of contracts suitably vague. The LP had just come onto the market, and large parts of the music had never been recorded before.” Brendel gladly took advantage of the situation and signed a contract with Vox Records (“a very odd company, but they gave me the chance to record practically all of Beethoven’s piano music”). Although many of his early recordings were produced and sold cheaply, “we were just grateful for the chance to be heard by the outside world [so] we didn’t ask very much about fees and contracts.”
However carefully planned, Brendel’s thirty-year plan could still sometimes run into a dead end, and he admitted to experiencing periods of “stagnation” in Vienna. His lifelong aversion to publicity did not help him, nor did his own reserved presence on the concert platform. As he puts it, “I really had no early success worth talking about. I did not look the kind of person who appeals to a large audience when I was twenty-five. I didn’t appeal to mothers, and I pulled a lot of faces. I was really a kind of outsider, and I wanted to be an outsider. I looked at the audience with a kind of irony or contempt as a necessary evil; in those early years I never knew how to communicate what I was doing.”
In spite of all this, Brendel’s playing finally came to the attention of a wider audience in 1969, when he had given a Beethoven recital in London that he himself considered unremarkable. Several influential people at the concert thought otherwise, and the next day Brendel’s agent received a flood of career-changing offers from several British record labels: for Brendel it was like a slowly heating kettle finally coming to the boil. Soon afterwards he moved to London, where he has lived ever since.
Alfred Brendel and his adopted city were perhaps made for each other. British music lovers immediately warmed to the pianist’s modest, stoical manner, his learning and his idiosyncratic sense of humour. Above all they liked his understated way of performing. The feelings soon became mutual. “Perhaps one reason why I like London,” Brendel said, “is that the English have very little gift for fanaticism.”
After his first marriage in Vienna had collapsed, Brendel found love again in London too, with the German television producer Irene Semler. The couple had three children, including a son, Adrian, a cellist who has since built a successful professional career in his own right (“I admire him immensely,” his proud father says of him).
Brendel’s own playing, with its long and slow development, was now approaching its peak. Although in his youth he had performed a wide range of music, in maturity he built his repertoire around four Austro-German giants, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven and Schubert: Romantic sensibilities within classical structures always seemed to suit him best.
According to one observer, he was able to “win his way to that ‘second simplicity’ in which the listener gets the feeling that the music is not being played but is happening of its own accord.” Brendel himself felt he had learned to communicate better with the audience: “my face-pulling has calmed down,” he said in 1981. “And now that I play in larger halls, I am far enough away for people to notice it less! In general the audience has got used to my oddities.”
By this stage he had come to regard performing as a form of acting, in which each piece of music is like a character: “I have always felt that actors are a source of inspiration,” he explains. “On stage they have to transform into a character, to portray many different figures: I feel them to be my colleagues… Great acting in the theatre and on the screen has constantly inspired the desire to play roles as a musical performer and to treat pieces of music as characters.”
Another important part of Brendel’s playing was his ability to see the piano’s potential for transformation: “great piano works have been receptacles for many musical ideas - in the different shades of orchestral, vocal and instrumental music - and not products tailored primarily to a particular vintage of a particular keyboard maker. The greatest piano composers, with the exception of Chopin, were all composers of ensemble music, at times chiefly so. The score contains in latent form an abundance of ideas derived from other musical media; the pianist must bring them out as clearly as possible.”
Despite his intense approach to his field, Brendel was never a man who gets stuck in his music all day long (“I could not bear the thought of music swallowing me up entirely”). From youth he has shown a wide interest in other arts such as literature, the visual arts, architecture and philosophy. Having once been such a good painter that some of his works were exhibited in Graz, he later became a skilled writer who produced “some of the best music writing ever written”, as fellow pianist and protégé Till Fellner puts it.
And for all his analytical, learned manner, Brendel has never threatened to turn into an intellectual pedant. An unrestrained sense of humour has always lurked just beneath his seemingly serious exterior - perhaps another survival tactic from his early years in Nazi-occupied Europe. “Alongside the wonderful sense of order that I got from music, I learned to appreciate nonsense,” he once said, and “not only the poetic realm discovered by Edward Lear but the absurd part of reality.”
Later in life Brendel was able to channel some of that “nonsense” into his own absurd poetry. It was like finding “something that, to my mind, cheers me up voluntarily.” He has since published several collections of poetry, one of the best known of which describes a pianist who grows an extra index finger during a performance and with which he then “exposes the stubborn cougher in the hall” as well as seductively “beckons to the lady in the third row.”
As an international star, Brendel’s career continued to shine brightly into the new century. Although a stiff back eventually forced him to cut back some of his most demanding repertoire, he played as well as ever when he finally decided to retire from concert appearances in 2008 at the age of 77. Fortunately it was not a complete withdrawal from public life. Since then he has stayed busy, keeping a busy schedule of masterclasses, lectures, poetry readings and further writing (“I have found that it is possible to talk about music without talking nonsense, and I think one should always be a little witty”).
Summing up his career, Brendel recently said that “it is hard for me to understand when I found time to do everything: play, write, look, live, love. Although I never managed to be bored or idle, I always got enough sleep. Although I loved playing, I was never driven, and I went on stage of my own free will. When my concert career ended I did not shed a single tear. What does all this add up to? Life as a whole has remained rather mysterious.”
And his legacy? When he was once told that his retirement had left “a big hole in so many people’s lives”, the twinkling-eyed Brendel replied: “I was just glad I was able to leave something behind - even if it was a hole!”
The article was first published on Live Klassisk in July 2024.
