When Philip Glass Installed Dishwashers
article
D
David Hackett7 min read|15. May 2023
When Philip Glass installed dishwashers: How composers have made ends meet through the centuries
Making money is art. And working is art. And good business is the best art - Andy Warhol
Anyone who has ever tried a creative career knows the eternal question: can I realise my artistic dreams and make money at the same time?
And whether you are an aspiring composer, painter, writer or other artistic performer, you will soon discover that the answer to this question is roughly - no, maybe, not easily.
Making a living as an artist is experiencing capitalism at its harshest and most merciless. The spoils are always divided unevenly. Most of the wealth ends up in the hands of a very small minority, and the rest are chronically underpaid. No matter how talented you are, you very rarely earn a sufficient living from your art alone.
Composers, however, have a silver lining. As a musician you probably have other skills, such as teaching, playing or conducting, to fall back on. And it is usually through one of these that you get a roof over your head. The tricky part, of course, is making sure that paid work does not encroach too far on your creative time.
If you were a composer at any point in the last six hundred years, there were several ways of managing this delicate balancing act - doing what you were born to do, but without starving to death.
At first your career options were limited.
In the Middle Ages a composer’s best and surest livelihood was to work for the church, either as a director of music or as an organist. But there were obvious restrictions on what you could and could not do. Above all, you could write only sacred music.
After 1450 two things happened - the wealth and prestige of the Catholic Church began slowly to decline, while the size and political power of Europe’s nobility grew. Many top aristocratic families began to hire court musicians. Although salaried composers and musicians were still subject to certain restrictions, their duties were more varied and they were given a freer hand in what they wrote.
A third option was, of course, another path, namely producing music for the stage. In the Middle Ages and the early Renaissance this did not offer a particularly brilliant career. It generally meant making music (as both composer and performer) for a theatre troupe, often an uncertain and impoverished life.
Theatre work did not stay like that forever. The rise of opera after 1600 offered composers an alternative path to wealth. The downside was fierce competition to produce a hit. But for the lucky few who reached the top, large sums were on offer.
Until 1800 you were often treated only slightly better than a court servant.
If you worked as a composer for the church or the nobility, you had to put up with a low social status. In an aristocratic household you not only had to dress and behave in a certain way, but you were also not always granted basic human rights. When J. S. Bach (1685 - 1750) once had the audacity to inform his employer, the Duke of Weimar, that he wished to leave his post as Konzertmeister, the duke was so angry that he threw the valuable composer he had hired into prison for a month, hoping to force him to change his mind. The ploy, however, did not work on a man whose genius was probably matched only by his stubbornness.
Things improved only when Haydn broke free and laid a foundation that others could follow.
The same yoke of court service burdened Joseph Haydn (1732 - 1809) in the late 1700s. Although Haydn was by then one of Europe’s most famous composers, he remained trapped at his aristocratic employers’ remote estate on the border between Austria and Hungary, with only limited leave. He had to turn down many lucrative opportunities that came his way.
Fortunately his luck turned when his principal employer died in 1790. Although Haydn was kept on at the estate on a reduced salary, he also gained the professional freedom he had longed for so long. He left immediately for London, where professional, independent orchestras were for the first time putting on ticketed concerts for a large public. Various impresarios took the great man into their hands and offered him large sums for a symphony or an opera, and Haydn was not willing to miss out. On just two tours of Britain he earned as much money as in twenty years in his old job.
After 1800 there were new, independent ways of earning.
Haydn was one of the first to benefit from the changing social order. Ticketed concerts and the sharp increase in music publishers gave composers, for the first time, some independence from their old, wealthy patrons. The new public concerts also gave the virtuoso composer-performers of the 1800s (such as Hummel, Chopin, Liszt, Paganini, Brahms, Rubinstein and Saint-Saëns) the chance to earn large sums regardless of how their compositions fared.
Teaching can be drudgery... but also a source of inspiration.
Whether or not you are a performer, almost every composer has at some point turned to teaching, some more than others and some better than others. Beethoven, for example, had a reputation for shouting at his pupils (unless it was a beautiful countess) and once bit one of his pupils on the arm when the pupil had made a mess of a scale. But Beethoven was far from alone in approaching the profession with a certain dread.
Teaching could be hard work for those who relied on it as their main income. In middle age Gabriel Fauré (1845 - 1924) had to trudge ceaselessly around Paris giving piano lessons at various addresses. A life like that dragged him down: he was often tired and depressed, and his creative work suffered. His luck turned only when the Paris Conservatoire appointed him inspector of the provincial music conservatoires with better pay and more free time. Later he became director of the Conservatoire, at which point he had the power to ensure that his job description left plenty of room for creative work.
But there are also examples of composers who found so-called teaching drudgery useful for their art. Gustav Holst (1874 - 1934), who came from modest circumstances, was already earning a wage before graduating from the Royal College of Music in London. After a few disheartening years as an orchestral trombonist, his career and finances were at rock bottom, and he had to take on several teaching posts, first at a girls’ preparatory school and then at an adult education college in South London. Surprisingly, the prospect of a new career seemed to release in him a whole new level of creativity. From then on he began to write some of his best and most original music, including the famous Planets suite. Holst later considered what he had achieved in his teaching work to be as important as his compositions.
Music does not even have to be your main job.
Composers have quite often earned their living entirely separately from their musical activities. Alexander Borodin (1833 - 1887) was known in his lifetime primarily as a scientist rather than a composer. He gained considerable renown as a pioneer of organic chemistry, particularly for his work on aldehydes. At the same time he spent eighteen years of his free time writing his great opera Prince Igor. Although it was left unfinished, it is an indisputable masterpiece in its own right.
The early 1900s American avant-gardist Charles Ives (1874 - 1954) had an even more improbable second career. At night the horrified residents of his New York apartment building listened to the composer’s various cacophonous experiments at the piano. But by day Ives had a serious job in insurance, a career he pursued so successfully that he was eventually able to set up his own firm and retire wealthy at around fifty-five. Oddly enough, being freed from the day job did not make him more creative, and he stopped writing music at roughly the same time, although he lived for another three decades.
If Ives represents an interesting duality of career, the life of the Russian composer Vladimir Dukelsky (1903 - 1969) was almost a case of dual identity. In the 1920s Dukelsky was a promising young modernist composer in Paris, widely regarded as Prokofiev’s protégé. Across the Atlantic he built a quite different musical alter ego: in the United States he worked under the name Vernon Duke and became a popular songwriter and composer of Broadway musicals. One identity financed the other lifestyle and allowed him to go on writing his more serious music. But apparently this was not a trick that every composer could pull off.
In the end it does not matter how you make money…
Like opera, writing film music has offered another route to large incomes. But it is a hyper-competitive field in which only very few aspirants succeed - and it requires that you want to write film music in the first place.
The vast majority of composers have shown their ingenuity in other ways. The enfant terrible of modern music, John Cage (1912 - 1992), once worked at an advertising agency in New York, running campaigns and designing business and Christmas cards (perhaps it was in just such a working environment that Cage eventually came up with the idea of placing various office supplies between the strings of his piano!) Cage’s interest in graphic design clearly influenced the creation of his own highly distinctive, unconventional musical notation.
In recent times it has not been unusual to see composers supporting themselves with odd jobs. For years Philip Glass (b. 1937) took on a variety of manual jobs while making a name for himself as a composer. He worked as a plumber and a taxi driver in New York, and at times he got work from a removals firm. Art critic Robert Hughes of Time magazine was shocked to discover that Glass had once installed his dishwasher. Hughes protested that such work must be beneath a composer. “But you’re an artist,” Hughes told him. Glass replied “that I was an artist but that I was sometimes also a plumber and that he should go away and let me finish the job!”
… You just have to keep writing.
For some creative musicians, Glass’s approach is simply the logical endpoint. The present-day Canadian composer Chris Sivak (b. 1982) once described how even regular commissions did not bring him enough to live on. He realised that he would have to produce music at such a back-breaking pace - to earn a decent wage - that he would have to give up luxuries such as “sleep, daylight and grocery shopping...” Another danger was that “I would produce exponentially less work I was proud of. The scales would tip towards quantity at the expense of quality if I pushed a lot harder.”
In the end he decided to become an internet plumber, a job that involves “climbing telephone poles with climbing spikes, ladders or a cherry-picker truck, splicing fibre-optic, twisted-pair and coaxial cables, troubleshooting network problems and getting completely covered in dirt...”
But Sivak also realised that the alternative career did not have to have any detrimental effect on his composing. He found that he could still set aside the same amount of time for his creative work as before.
As he emphatically explains: “the only way to fail in art is to stop doing it. There is no reason why a composer could not be a plumber or an electrician instead of a teacher. You just have to keep writing.”
The article was first published on Live Klassisk in May 2023.
