It is tempting to regard social progress as an inevitable part of history, although it is often much more fragile than we think and far too easy to reverse.
If the 1800s are full of stories of women composers struggling to make their voices heard amid the clamour of a deeply male-dominated society, one might assume that the problem had been even worse in the hundred years before. But the opposite was the case. Throughout the 1700s it was not unusual for women (at least those from wealthy backgrounds) to be encouraged and even authorised to express themselves creatively. As a gifted singer and a highly successful opéra-comique composer, Sophie Gail (1775 - 1819) rode the wave of this more enlightened generation both in the final years of France’s Ancien Régime and afterwards, in the early, hopeful period of the French Revolution and its more democratic values.
Gail’s personal circumstances were favourable in other ways too. Her father was a leading surgeon (and in his time physician to Louis XVI), while her mother came from a family of lawyers and state officials and had received “an education that transcended her sex”, as her husband (possibly mischievously) put it. The family moved in fashionable artistic circles, and the evidently talented Sophie soon received piano and singing lessons from some of the best in France. She published her first music at the age of 14 and was only 19 when she married a professor of Hellenic studies twenty years her senior. The marriage was not a happy one: the spouses’ outlooks and personal tastes quickly proved clearly unsuited to each other, and in 1801 they separated.
As her family had in the meantime lost most of its fortune in the years following the Revolution, Sophie’s future looked anything but secure. Earning a living from her music for the first time nevertheless proved to be a liberation. For the next half decade she toured all over Europe as a professional singer and pianist, supplementing her income with published piano music and songs. The only concession Gail still made on account of her sex was that she allowed herself to be treated as a kind of “honorary amateur”. All her music was printed anonymously, and newspaper reviewers were not allowed to mention her name.
Not that Gail was in any way a submissive type. As her reputation grew, she founded a salon in Paris, which quickly became a focal point for some of the most prominent singers of her day. She lived colourfully and passionately and bore four children by four different fathers. She took further composition lessons, and her most famous teacher was François-Joseph Fétis - the Belgian composer and celebrated critic, who would later assess his pupil’s abilities: “the combination of gifts in her made her highly remarkable. Deeply musical, she accompanied a score surely and intelligently, sang with taste and great expressiveness, trained very good pupils and composed with ease little pieces of charm that achieved decisive popularity.”
Gail saved her most significant compositional output for the last six years of her life. Her opéra-comique, Les Deux Jaloux, caused a mild sensation when it was first performed in 1813. Critics compared it favourably with Mozart, and it was performed in Paris for the next twenty-six years, well beyond its creator’s lifetime. As another critic wrote in retrospect, Gail “proved that a young [female] composer can fight with the men, at least in the Opéra-Comique theatre… Sophie Gail’s name was on everyone’s lips, her music on every piano.” According to Fétis, the work’s success was “all the more remarkable because it was the first of its kind achieved by a woman”.
Although her next two opéras-comiques were relative failures, Gail returned to her peak with La Sérénade in 1818, the libretto of which was written by her near-namesake Sophie Gay. A popular romantic novelist and playwright, Gay was in a way Gail’s literary counterpart. The collaboration of the two women (they were known as “Sophie de la Musique” and “Sophie de la Parole”) could have been the beginning of something great - instead, and rather poignantly, it became a kind of end. The values of the Revolution changed quickly in France. As Jacqueline Letzter explains in Women Writing Opera: Creativity and Controversy in the Age of the French Revolution, Gail and Gay “were the last women opera composers and librettists who had lived through the Revolution and had personally felt the empowering effect that its rhetoric had on women. The women of the next generation would be brought up under the oppressive Napoleonic gender ideology, which discouraged women from competing with men in public life.” The restoration of the Bourbon monarchy in 1814 only pushed the country further back towards conservative values - perhaps an inevitable reaction to all the revolutionary turmoil of the preceding twenty-five years. In the 1820s the elderly French portrait painter Vigée Le Brun remarked sadly that although forty years earlier women had “reigned”, they had since been “dethroned”.
Sophie Gail had set a standard that few were allowed to follow. Anyone who dared to do so could be subjected to the harshest criticism, such as the composer and poet Louise Bertin, who felt that French critics had hurt her so personally after she wrote four operas in the 1820s and 30s that she was hardly able to write another note during the last forty years of her life.
Gail herself did not live to see this decline. Her own life was cut short in 1819, when she fell fatally ill with a lung disease. Her old teacher Fétis wrote an extensive (and warm) obituary of her, which for several decades appeared in the weighty work Biographie Universelle des Musiciens: “Possessing great wit and an amiable character, she did not seem to attach any value to these advantages… She had many friends, and was so rarely fortunate as to keep them.”
The article was first published on Live Klassisk in September 2023.