Whom the Gods Love...

article
D
David Hackett9 min read|6. February 2025
Den som gudarna älskar...
In the history of Western music there are few things more poignant than youthful genius struck down in its prime.
Here we examine (and celebrate) the lives of five lesser-known composers from the last three centuries, all of whom briefly lit up the sky before returning to the shadows all too soon.
Giovanni Battista Pergolesi (Born 4 January 1710, Jesi. Died 16 March 1736, Pozzuoli)
Our first composer, Giovanni Pergolesi, was the James Dean of Baroque music: a rising star one moment, gone the next, and talked about for ever after. In a ridiculously short career he managed to achieve what many composers struggle to reach in an entire lifetime.
Born in 1710 in Jesi, on Italy’s east coast, it was clear early on that the young Giovanni had an unusual musical gift. At the age of 15 he was sent to Naples to study at the Conservatorio dei Poveri di Gesù Cristo, where he soon gained a reputation as a skilled violinist, organist and composer.
Pergolesi’s big breakthrough came at the tender age of 23, with his opera seria Il Prigionier Superbo (The Proud Prisoner). But it was not Il Prigionier itself that made the audience cheer, but rather the comic (buffa) intermezzo in two acts entitled La Serva Padrona (The Maid as Mistress) that Pergolesi had slipped into the middle of the work. This cheeky piece about a maid who outwits her master quickly became hugely popular in its own right and was the 1700s equivalent of a viral hit.
It was so popular that when it was later performed in Paris it triggered the so-called “Querelle des Bouffons” (The Quarrel of the Comic Actors) - a heated debate between supporters of serious French opera and enthusiasts for the new Italian comic style. Pergolesi became the unintentional poster boy of this operatic duel.
Despite his growing success, Pergolesi’s health was poor. Afflicted by a deformed leg, probably caused by polio, and by the deadly onset of tuberculosis, he finally sought refuge in a Franciscan monastery in Pozzuoli.
It was here that he composed his best-known work, a setting of the Stabat Mater. According to legend, he wrote the music in a feverish frenzy, racing against time to finish before his approaching death. Whether or not that story is entirely accurate, it undeniably lends his tale a dramatic glow.
On 16 March 1736, at the tender age of 26, Giovanni Battista Pergolesi took his final bow. He was laid to rest in the Franciscan monastery and left behind a mark on the musical world that would influence composers for generations.
Juan Crisóstomo Arriaga (Born 27 January 1806, Bilbao. Died 17 January 1826, Paris)
Now we come to a composer who sadly did not even reach his third decade. But not everything was ill-fated in Arriaga’s short but brilliant life. He came from a musical family in Bilbao in northern Spain and had one of the grandest names of any composer - Juan Crisóstomo Jacobo Antonio de Arriaga y Balzola. He also shared a birthday with Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (exactly fifty years later) and was, just like Mozart, a child prodigy. For those reasons he was later called “the Spanish Mozart”.
By the age of eleven Arriaga had already written his first opera, Los Esclavos Felices (The Happy Slaves). “Without any knowledge whatsoever of the theory of harmony, Juan Crisóstomo wrote a Spanish opera with wonderful and entirely original ideas,” was the verdict of one of his teachers several years later.
At the age of 15 Arriaga was more than ready to leave Bilbao and continue his studies at the Paris Conservatoire. When the conservatoire’s stern director Luigi Cherubini first heard one of his works, he exclaimed eagerly: “Who wrote this?” When he learned that it was the young Spaniard, he replied: “Marvellous - you are music itself!”
Arriaga excelled not only in his studies but even became an assistant teacher at the conservatoire, astonishing both pupils and teachers with his sophisticated mastery of harmony and counterpoint. On one occasion he composed a fugue for eight voices, which Cherubini is said to have declared “a masterpiece.”
It is impossible to know how this inspiring young man would have developed had he not tragically died of a lung disease ten days before his 20th birthday. Although his creative life was brutally short, he still managed to write a handful of works (including a symphony and three string quartets) that remain quietly impressive for their originality and emotional depth and show a maturity that belied his tender age.
Julius Reubke (Born 23 March 1834, Hausneindorf. Died 3 June 1858, Dresden)
The early 1800s seem to have been a particularly bad time for anyone who wanted to become a great composer and at the same time manage to live a normal long life (apart from poor Arriaga, think of Weber, Schubert, Chopin and Mendelssohn...).
Poor Julius Reubke was particularly unlucky and was snatched away almost before he had begun. He was born in the German village of Hausneindorf (in the Harz mountains) and came from a family with deep musical traditions. His father Adolf was a significant organ builder, and two of his brothers would follow in their father’s footsteps. But Julius had other plans - he did not want to build organs, he wanted to play them. And above all to create exciting, groundbreaking new music for them.
At the age of 17 he was already studying at the conservatoire in Berlin and became friends with the conductor Hans von Bülow, who was so impressed (“the conservatoire’s best pupil”) that he passed Reubke’s name on to Franz Liszt. Liszt in turn invited Reubke to continue his studies with him in Weimar.
The young Reubke might have felt that the world lay open before him, had he not already shown signs of advanced tuberculosis. Aware that time was short, he drove himself to new heights in Weimar and wrote the two monumental works on which his reputation still rests today: a piano sonata in B flat minor and an organ sonata on Psalm 94 (both from 1857).
Although the former shows a certain influence from Liszt, it more than holds its own as a major work. The latter was Reubke’s masterpiece and is regarded today as one of the great organ works of the 1800s. Barely recognisable as “traditional” organ music, Reubke’s sonata is full of fiery, virtuosic writing, a thunderstorm in musical form. It is based on a particularly grim psalm and is dominated by minor keys, and the organ often sounds as though it were conveying the wrath of an Old Testament God.
For any other 23-year-old composer, such an astonishing piece of music would have been the beginning of something great. But for Reubke it was already the end. He spent most of the next year slowly dying, until in June 1858 he finally gave in to the inevitable.
“Truly no one can feel the loss that art has suffered in your Julius more deeply,” Liszt wrote to Reubke senior, “than the one who with admiring sympathy has followed his noble, persevering and successful endeavours over the past years, and who will always faithfully remember his friendship.”
But while we are left to wonder what more Reubke might have achieved, we can still be grateful for the two wonderful and for ever fresh-sounding sonatas that he left behind.
Guillaume Lekeu (Born 20 January 1870, Heusy. Died 21 January 1894, Poitiers)
Like Julius Reubke, Guillaume Lekeu’s name would surely be better known today had his life not been so cruelly cut short - in his case by a contaminated sorbet (which led to typhoid fever) the day after his 24th birthday. At his death he was already an established composer with several significant works behind him.
Although fundamentally a late Romantic, influenced by both César Franck and Gabriel Fauré, Lekeu had a highly original mind and a naturally forward-looking sensibility. Had he lived longer one gets the feeling that he would have had something interesting to say for many decades more - indeed, one suspects, even in the post-Romantic world of Schoenberg and Stravinsky.
Lekeu’s childhood was divided between the picturesque village of Heusy near Verviers in Belgium and Poitiers in central France, before the family finally ended up in Paris in the late 1880s. Although he had proved himself a driven musician, he did not really decide on a musical career until after a pilgrimage to Bayreuth in 1889 to hear some of Richard Wagner’s operas (it was perhaps the 1800s equivalent of a teenager going to a rock concert and coming home with dreams of starting a band).
After returning to Paris he continued his private composition studies with two eminent teachers, César Franck and Vincent d'Indy. It was d’Indy who would hone his orchestration and encourage his ambitions. In 1891 Lekeu competed for the Belgian Prix de Rome and won an impressive second prize with the cantata Andromède.
Over the following three years Lekeu built impressively on that success, with a series of chamber works and orchestral pieces in which his music showed a growing emotional depth and an increasingly innovative way of structuring his ideas. Of his way of composing he once said: “what is more, it will be strange, mad, abominable, whatever you like, but at least it will be original”. His best-known work is his wonderful violin sonata in G major, commissioned by the famous violinist Eugène Ysaÿe.
Then came, sadly, the contaminated sorbet. Lekeu was buried in a small churchyard in his childhood village of Heusy and left behind a life’s work that still arouses interest and that keeps his voice a living part of the classical music canon.
Lili Boulanger (Born 21 August 1893, Paris. Died 15 March 1918, Mézy-sur-Seine)
Marie-Juliette Olga “Lili” Boulanger was born into a family with such great cultural credentials that many others in her position might have felt a little intimidated. She shared her childhood home (in Paris’s 9th arrondissement) with her mother Raissa Myshetskaya, a Russian princess and singer, her ageing father Ernest Boulanger, a conductor and composer of comic operas who had won the prestigious Prix de Rome as early as 1835, and her older sister Nadia, who was destined to become one of the great music educators of the 1900s.
But Lili seemed to take it all in her stride. Although there must have been a certain rivalry between the sisters, Nadia was also an important support and source of inspiration for Lili throughout her short life. Of the two, it was probably Lili who showed the most promise and originality as a composer.
Despite her obvious gifts, Lili was already plagued by significant cracks in her health. She had suffered from chronic illnesses since early childhood, including a bronchopneumonia she contracted at the age of two that had weakened her immune system. These health problems often interrupted her studies and creative work, but they never dampened her determination - nor her courage.
In 1912, at the age of 19, she decided to compete for the prestigious Prix de Rome. She was forced to abandon her first attempt after collapsing during the exam, but returned the following year and this time took first prize with her cantata Faust et Hélène. It was a dizzying achievement, not least because she was the first woman ever to win the competition.
For the rest of her short life Lili composed several more cantatas, together with various vocal and orchestral works. Her compositions were always forward-looking for their time and built on Debussy’s impressionistic symbolism, while she remained alert to the very latest musical currents in France. But the long and exciting creative career that now seemed to lie ahead of the young woman was sadly not granted to her, as she died of intestinal tuberculosis in March 1918, only 24 years old.
Her older sister Nadia had an entirely different lot and lived for another sixty years, famed for her teaching at the Paris Conservatoire, as well as at the Royal College of Music in London and the Juilliard School in New York.
As with Pergolesi, Arriaga, Reubke and Lekeu, we can only wonder what more Lili Boulanger might have achieved as a composer, had she only been given a comparable amount of time.
The article was first published on Live Klassisk in February 2025.

More César Franck

More Franz Liszt

Audience top 10

The most popular concerts coming up
Read on

More articles

All articles →
This week's recommendations · 22. Nov · 2 min readBruckner med Bancroft i Stockholm och Christian Zacharias i Göteborg

Veckan bjuder på både symfonisk tyngd och intim kammarmusik, med flera framstående artister på landets scener. ...

10 concerts in the article →
This week's recommendations · 15. Nov · 1 min readCanellakis and Hadelich in Gothenburg, Christina Nilsson with Wagner in Stockholm

Göteborgs Symfoniker inleder veckan med ett uppmärksammat gästspel. Dirigenten Karina Canellakis och ...

10 concerts in the article →
article · 2. Nov · 2 min readAre you an organiser? Here is how your concerts get onto Live Klassisk

Live Klassisk är en konsertkalender för klassisk musik i Danmark, Norge, Sverige och Finland. Den här artikeln ...

article · 2. Nov · 2 min readChristmas concerts 2026: Lucia, the Christmas Oratorio and Messiah across Sweden

Från första advent till veckan före jul fylls kyrkor och konserthus med julmusik. Här är ett urval av årets ...

13 concerts in the article →